On Thursday April 10 we discussed Smarthomes, and whether it was something we could all aspire to. Several members used “smart plugs” “…a Wi-Fi-enabled power adapter that allows you to remotely control the power to connected devices, like lights, fans, or appliances, using a smartphone app or voice commands. Essentially, it transforms ordinary outlets and devices into “smart” ones, enabling automation and remote control.” (Google Gemini) and two members were able to monitor their homes remotely through cameras and sensors over the Internet.
We watched this “Concept” video of a Smart Home from Brigham Young University (It’s quite old – 11 years)
Then we discussed the points raised by this article from July 2024: Smart Home: Definition, How They Work, Pros and Cons . Chris played Devil’s Advocate and commented on the security risks (Wi Fi can be hacked, Denial of Service hacker attacks using internet connected devices have been reported) and costs. Making an entire home “Smart” with remote controlled garage doors, security cameras etc. can be expensive although Smart plugs, which work with Alexa or Google Home and a phone app are very cheap. Most members programmed such plugs themselves to manage water heaters and lights remotely from their smartphones. The article said the “Smart home appliances come with self-learning skills. They can learn the homeowner’s schedules and make adjustments as needed.” .. though this didn’t seem to be the case with the kit JCC members used. Chris uses simple digital or mechanical programmable plugs (i.e. not connected to the Internet).
Chris asked what would happen if there was a power cut. Obviously the house would lose power and its internet connection. One member had a battery backup solar power system and was therefore protected against power cuts. If the Internet went down, then you wouldn’t be able to communicate with the house, though a total outage was unlikely, unless there was damage to the fibre by an errant lorry for example. An alternative would be to use a 4G/5G router rather than fibre for the Internet connection since this didn’t rely on physical cables. However communication lapses seem to be occurring more frequently these days. Chris related a recent incident where the Denia Town hall phone system didn’t work for five days: https://lamarina.eldiario.es/2025/04/08/el-ayuntamiento-de-denia-incomunicado-desde-hace-cinco-dias/
The whole house would have to have WiFi coverage, which is best distributed through Ethernet cables though cabling an old house would face challenges. Managing all these devices could be a bit complicated, especially for people unfamiliar with technology. One problem is that there are several different systems on the market and these can be incompatible.
Judging from articles on the Internet the main use seems to be for household security, though savings on energy consumption are supposed to be possible via the programmed use of heating and air con etc.
Chris remarked that the installation of Smart security systems seemed to go hand in hand with the tendency to turn houses into fortresses with high walls and gates and security cameras all over the place, leading to an atmosphere of mistrust and fear. This is perhaps a symptom of the personal isolation which today’s remotely connected world has created.
In summary…
” Is a Smart Home Worth It?
It can be. You must do the research to determine whether the potential convenience, added security, and cost savings over time outweigh the cost to install a full home system. Consider using individual smart home products first to learn how well they fit your lifestyle and budget.”
We then watched this amusing video, extolling the virtues of old-fashioned technology:
Later, Peter recommended another comedy sketch describing the dangers of Home Automation. This video not suitable for people who have a nervous disposition!
Chris Betterton-Jones – Knowledge Junkie